Loading blog content, please wait...
By Sara Anglin - State Farm Insurance Agent
That Fender Bender in the Kroger Lot? Here's When to Call You're backing out of a spot at the Kroger on Gallatin Pike, someone else is doing the same th...
You're backing out of a spot at the Kroger on Gallatin Pike, someone else is doing the same thing three feet away, and there's that soft crunch nobody wants to hear. Two cars, low speed, no injuries, a couple of scuffed bumpers. Now you're both standing there in the summer heat trying to figure out what happens next. Do you swap numbers and move on? Call the police? Call your insurance? File anything at all?
The honest answer is that it depends on a few things you can size up in the first couple of minutes, and knowing them ahead of time makes the whole thing a lot less stressful.
Before you decide anything, get the basics locked in. Even a minor bump can turn into a headache later if the other driver disappears and you've got nothing written down.
Trade names, phone numbers, insurance company names, and policy numbers. Snap photos of both cars, both license plates, the damage from a few angles, and the general scene, including where you both were in the lot. If there are witnesses grabbing their carts nearby, a name and number helps. Parking lots are private property, which means there's often no clear right-of-way the way there is on Ellington Parkway, and that can make fault genuinely murky. Photos settle a lot of arguments that words can't.
The one thing to avoid: standing there deciding whose fault it was and putting it in writing. You don't have to admit fault, and you shouldn't guess at it. Document what happened, not who's to blame. That part gets sorted out later with the facts.
For a true fender bender in a private lot with no injuries and minor damage, Metro Nashville police often won't dispatch an officer to write a report. Their resources go to injury crashes and incidents on public roads. That's normal, and it's not a sign you did anything wrong by calling.
That said, there are moments when you absolutely want a report on file. Call if anyone is hurt, even a little, or complains of pain later that day. Call if the other driver seems impaired, is aggressive, or won't give you their information. And call if the damage is more than cosmetic, because a report becomes valuable documentation if the story changes later.
Tennessee has specific rules about when a crash has to be reported. Under state law, you're required to report a crash that causes injury, death, or property damage above a set dollar threshold, even one on private property. The Tennessee Department of Safety and Homeland Security lays out the current requirements, and it's worth knowing the threshold is easier to hit than people expect once you factor in what body work actually costs now.
Here's the part people wrestle with the most. They've got a small dent, both cars drove away fine, and they're weighing whether calling their agent is going to send their rate through the roof. So they sit on it for a few days, wondering.
Call me. Even for the small stuff. A conversation is not a claim.
That's the piece a lot of folks miss. You can call, walk me through exactly what happened, and ask what your options look like before you decide to file anything. We can talk through whether the repair is likely to land above or below your deductible, whether the other driver's insurance should be handling it, and what a claim would actually mean for you. Sometimes the smart move is to file. Sometimes, if the damage is genuinely minor and you're clearly at fault for a small amount, paying out of pocket makes more sense than running it through insurance. You get to make that call with real information instead of a guess.
If the other driver was at fault, their liability coverage should be covering your repair, and I can help you understand how that process works and what to expect if their insurer drags its feet. If you're not sure who was at fault, or if the other driver already left, your own collision coverage and, depending on the situation, your uninsured motorist coverage may come into play. That's exactly the kind of thing worth understanding before you're standing in a parking lot needing it.
A few patterns come up again and again with lot incidents around town.
The first is assuming a private lot means insurance doesn't apply. It does. Your coverage follows your car whether you're on I-40 or in the Publix lot in Green Hills.
The second is the low-speed reveal. A bumper that looks fine can hide sensor damage, and modern bumpers with parking sensors and cameras cost far more to repair than they used to. What looked like a fifty-dollar scuff turns into a real repair once the shop pulls the cover. That's another reason a two-minute call before you settle up in cash is worth making.
The third is time. Tennessee gives you a window to file, but memories fade and the other driver's cooperation tends to fade with them. The sooner you document and the sooner we talk, the smoother it goes.
If you take away one thing, let it be this: get the other driver's information and photos before anyone leaves, call the police when there's injury, impairment, a dispute, or damage that's clearly more than cosmetic, and call me for everything, because talking through your options costs you nothing and a claim is a decision you make with me, not something that happens the moment you dial.
A fender bender in the Kroger lot is annoying. It doesn't have to be complicated. Keep this handy, and if it ever happens, you'll already know your next move.